HR & Payroll Software

Gusto vs BrightHR

Both are hr & payroll software. The short answer: choose Gusto if you are uS small businesses running payroll; choose BrightHR if you are uK small businesses managing holidays, rotas and HR documents.

Some links on this site are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Our rankings are not for sale; sponsored placements are always labelled.

Gusto logo GustoBrightHR logo BrightHR
Best forUS small businesses running payrollUK small businesses managing holidays, rotas and HR documents
Free planNo (trial may exist)No (trial may exist)
PricingSee providerSee provider
Built for IndiaGlobalGlobal
CategoriesHR & Payroll SoftwareHR & Payroll Software
Strengths
  • Easy US payroll
  • Automatic tax filings
  • Easy holiday and absence management
  • Employment-law advice line
  • Mobile app for staff
Watch out for
  • US only
  • Payroll is separate
  • Advice features depend on country
Visit GustoVisit BrightHR

Which should you choose?

Gusto: Payroll, benefits and HR platform for US businesses.

BrightHR: HR software with holiday booking, rotas, absence tracking and employment-law advice for UK, Ireland, Australia and Canada.

The best way to decide is to run the same week of real work through both — most offer a free plan or trial — and compare how long tasks take, what your team prefers, and the total cost for your number of users including renewal pricing.

Not sure either fits? See all hr & payroll software compared.